
I was never very fond of New York’s personality but I watched her shows—all of them—even that awful New York Goes to Work. I watched consistently, like the reality TV junkie that I am (don’t judge me), because I couldn’t turn away from her awesomely bad foolery.
I am very fond of Snooki (I said don’t judge me! By the way, I hate Domino’s Pizza). There, I admitted it, I watched Jersey Shore. If it’s any consolation, I resisted temptation for most of the season, even after news of the infamous punching incident spread like wildfire, but then, one boring Sunday afternoon I turned on MTV and behold, a marathon. Now that the season is over, there’s already buzz about Snooki getting her own show. It’s still being shopped around but it’s tentatively titled, Snooking For Love. I couldn’t help but think had it not been for New York, Snooki might not have that opportunity but Snooki is definitely the bigger diva. Let’s break it down.
New York

Bio: Tiffany “New York” Pollard made her debut on season one of Flavor of Love as the difficult, eye-rolling, cat fighting, cursing-chicks-out left and right contestant who became a show standout. She made it to the end but didn’t get picked. When Flavor of Love 2 came to the tube, she was invited back to compete again only to suffer the same fate ,but it ended up working in her favor because she got three of her own spin-off shows.
Style: New York was fond of massive makeup, tacky clothing (Read: mall couture) and big barrel curls. She also had ridiculously massive fake breasts that only emphasized her garish appearance.
Divatude: She suffers from a false sense of flyness.
Defining Moment(s): New York had several defining moments. She got spit on in season one of Flavor of Love, mooned Flavor Flav in season two, got embarrassed on national TV when what she thought was an engagement was called off and has had several arguments—most significantly, the one where Deelishis attempted to beat her down during a Flavor of Love reunion special. It’s surprising that she has never actually been punched (at least not on TV).
Man Eater Quotient: She fancied herself a man eater but always ended up being the one who got played.
Likability Factor: She’s not likable—and yes, she’s a walking stereotype, but she’s entertaining.
Snooki

Bio: Nicole “Snooki” (aka Snook aka Snickers aka any other variation you can think of) Polizzi is the self-proclaimed “Guidette” from Poughkeepsie, New York who debuted on Jersey Shore and stole the show. When it came to outshining the cast, she was an unlikely character; however, there was something about her that people couldn’t help but love.
Style: Her style was very, er, Peggy Bundy sans the excess leopard print (although there was some at times) and she had orange skin from over-tanning (not cute). Being short and squat didn’t stop her from wearing tight clothing, parading around in scant bikinis and underwear (hence the hot tub incident), and let’s not forget her signature bouffant hairstyle that made Bump It stocks shoot through the roof.
Divatude: Snooki was short, but she had no qualms about speaking her mind and telling people straight where to go.
Defining Moment(s): The show barely got to air before news of the infamous incident where she got socked in the face by a man in a bar spread over the web and TV news like wildfire, but it didn’t stop there. She got attacked by two random girls who stopped by the Jersey Shore house to visit some of her male roommates because she spoke her mind about the fact that she didn’t want them there (ie, she kicked them out). And when “The Situation” insulted her weight because she called out his jackass behavior, she revealed that she had struggled with an eating disorder throughout her high school years. Basically, Snooki kept it real. It may have gotten her beat up (mentally and physically) a lot, but being silent is even worse, so props to Snickers.
Man Eater Quotient: Her sole purpose at the shore was to find a man, but that never seemed to work out. Between one of her guys getting drunk and throwing up next to her while on a couch, accidentally hitting on a gay guy on a date (who eventually walked away from her when his date came to regulate) and discovering that another crush of hers had been celibate for several years and didn’t plan to break that any time soon, her dating situations were always fails.
Likability Factor: Again, Snooki kept it real. According to Italian American advancement groups, all of the Jersey Shore kids represented negative stereotypes. But Snooki always stayed true to who she was—spandex, bouffant, loose lips and all—and didn’t care who liked it or not.
Winner: Snooki, hands down! I now pronounce Snooki the Realest Reality TV Diva!